European Commission Hits Apple With €1.8 Billion Fine Over Spotify Dispute

Following a complaint lodged by Spotify, the European Commission has imposed an antitrust fine exceeding 1.8 billion euros ($1.95bn) on Apple. This significant penalty, announced on Monday, marks a first for Apple in terms of antitrust fines from Brussels. Apple has expressed its intention to appeal against the fine. The dispute traces back to 2019 when Spotify accused Apple of hindering music streaming services from alerting users about alternative payment options outside of its App Store.

The European Union's competition watchdog has deemed Apple's restrictive practices as unfair trading conditions, a stance echoed in a previous decision by the Dutch antitrust authority in 2021 concerning dating app providers. "For a decade, Apple abused its dominant position in the market for the distribution of music streaming apps through the App Store," stated EU antitrust chief Margrethe Vestager. She highlighted how Apple's actions, which restricted developers from informing customers about cheaper services outside the Apple ecosystem, contravened EU antitrust regulations.

Apple's Response and Future Implications

Apple has criticized the European Commission's decision, arguing that it was made without any substantial evidence of consumer harm and that it overlooks the competitive nature of the market. The tech giant pointed out that Spotify, which benefits most from this decision, has engaged with the European Commission extensively, over 65 times during the investigation. Apple also noted that Spotify does not pay any commission to Apple since it sells its subscriptions via its website, not the App Store.

This fine against Apple is part of the EU's broader initiative to regulate Big Tech companies, which has seen Google fined in three cases totaling 8.25 billion euros ($8.95bn) over the past decade. Additionally, the EU has initiated another antitrust investigation into Apple's mobile payments service, with Apple proposing to open up its tap-and-go systems to competitors as a potential settlement.

The directive for Apple to eliminate its App Store restrictions aligns with the forthcoming EU Digital Markets Act (DMA), which mandates compliance by March 7. This act aims to ensure a fairer and more competitive digital market within the European Union.

Via