Apple to Remove Watch Series 9 and Watch Ultra 2 from US Stores Amidst Patent Dispute

In a significant development for the tech industry, Apple is set to remove the Watch Series 9 and Watch Ultra 2 from its stores in the US. This move comes in response to an International Trade Commission (ITC) ruling that has banned the sale of these devices due to a patent dispute with medical device maker Masimo. The ban will come into effect post-3 pm ET on December 21 for online sales, and starting December 24 for in-store purchases.

Dispute Over Patented SpO2 Sensor Technology

The core of the dispute lies in Apple’s alleged use of Masimo’s patented technology within the SpO2 (blood oxygen) sensors of the Watch Series 9 and Watch Ultra 2. Despite the ruling, Apple spokesperson Nikki Rothberg has stated that the company "strongly disagrees" with the ITC's decision and is actively exploring "legal and technical options" to ensure the products remain available to consumers.

Legal Battles and Presidential Oversight

Masimo has filed two lawsuits against Apple, one in the US District Court and another with the ITC. The ultimate fate of the Apple Watch models now rests with US President Joe Biden, who has the authority to either uphold or veto the ban. Historically, such vetoes are rare, though there is precedent with former President Barack Obama overturning an ITC ban on the iPhone 4 in 2013. Interestingly, President Biden has previously chosen not to intervene in an ITC ruling against an Apple Watch feature related to EKG technology.

Impact on Sales and Functionality

The ITC ruling does not affect Apple Watch Series 9 and Watch Ultra 2 units that have already been sold; these devices will continue to function normally and receive full technical support. Additionally, the ban does not extend to units currently in stock at third-party retailers such as BestBuy and Amazon. However, Apple will no longer be able to restock these models after December 25. Notably, this ban is exclusive to the US market and does not impact previous models or sales in other countries.

The impending removal of the Apple Watch Series 9 and Watch Ultra 2 from US stores signifies a considerable setback for Apple amidst the busy holiday season. As the company navigates this legal hurdle, consumers and industry observers alike are keenly awaiting the decision of President Biden on this matter.